Reviews

Bourbon is a work of art, and we review it by tasting.

Explore our growing library of bourbon and American whiskey reviews, updated regularly with new releases, familiar favorites, and bottles worth knowing. Every review is grounded in careful tasting and honest evaluation, from aroma and flavor to finish, value, and the overall drinking experience.

Whether you’re deciding what to buy or simply looking for your next great pour, start here.

Sort by Whiskey Type
Review Scott Oetjen Review Scott Oetjen

Peerless Toasted Rye Whiskey

Rye isn’t usually subtle. It tends to arrive loud, full of spice, snap, and sharp edges. It kicks the door open and lets you know it’s there. But every now and then, rye slows down.

Read More
Review Arthur Cherry Review Arthur Cherry

Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Rye Whiskey / A925

For years, Heaven Hill’s Elijah Craig line has been a bourbon lover’s staple; small batch, barrel proof, toasted, you name it. But this time, they’ve gone where Elijah Craig’s never gone before: full barrel proof rye.

Read More
Review Arthur Cherry Review Arthur Cherry

Still Austin Cask Strength Rye Whiskey

For years, Texas whiskey has been carving out its own identity—grain-forward, bold, and unapologetically different. And at the heart of that movement is Still Austin, an upstart distillery doing things the hard way: grain-to-glass, locally sourced, and rooted in artistry.

Read More