Reviews

Bourbon is a work of art, and we review it by tasting.

Explore our growing library of bourbon and American whiskey reviews, updated regularly with new releases, familiar favorites, and bottles worth knowing. Every review is grounded in careful tasting and honest evaluation, from aroma and flavor to finish, value, and the overall drinking experience.

Whether you’re deciding what to buy or simply looking for your next great pour, start here.

Sort by Whiskey Type
Review Scott Oetjen Review Scott Oetjen

Barrell Bourbon / Batch 38

Some bourbon distilleries spend years perfecting a single recipe. Barrell takes a different approach. Rather than making whiskey, Barrell Craft Spirits builds it.

Read More
Review Scott Oetjen Review Scott Oetjen

Duck Club High Brass Bourbon Whiskey

Some bottles arrive with a lot more baggage than others. Duck Club High Brass Bourbon comes with outdoor lifestyle branding, a celebrity connection, hunting imagery, and enough online debate to make you wonder whether people are talking about the whiskey or the marketing.

Read More
Review Arthur Cherry Review Arthur Cherry

Blood Oath Pact 12 Bourbon

There was a time when every new Blood Oath release felt like an automatic buy. The annual series built a reputation around mystery, limited availability, unique finishes, and the promise that master distiller John Rempe had discovered something special.

Read More
Review Scott Oetjen Review Scott Oetjen

Barrell Bourbon Cigar Blend

Barrell Bourbon Cigar Blend is one of those bottles that sounds gimmicky until you actually sit down with it. The name makes you expect something smoky, over-oaked, and built purely for cigar lounges and leather chairs.

Read More
Review Scott Oetjen Review Scott Oetjen

Augusta Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey

Augusta Distillery Small Batch Bourbon is exactly the kind of bottle that fills a gap you didn’t realize was missing. Known more for premium, higher-priced releases, Augusta steps into the mid-shelf space here with something more approachable and surprisingly complete.

Read More
Review Scott Oetjen Review Scott Oetjen

Green River Full Proof Wheated Bourbon

Green River Full Proof Wheated takes a familiar profile and turns up the intensity. Bottled at 109.3 proof and priced around $50, it lands right in the middle shelf where value and flavor have to deliver.

Read More