The Stats
French toast and bourbon sound like a pretty good combination. But can you actually make a whiskey taste like French toast without taking things too far?
That's essentially the experiment behind Barrell French Toast(ed), a blend of mature bourbons finished in French oak barrels with different levels of toast.
We've had some great experiences with Barrell's finished whiskeys, including its Toasted American Oak release. So we were curious what would happen when they swapped American oak for French oak. And whether the result would be worth $160.
The Whiskey Behind the Bottle
Barrell Craft Spirits has built a reputation for blending mature whiskeys and experimenting with different finishes. French Toast(ed) is part of its Red Label Series, which explores what different types of oak can bring to well-aged bourbon.
For this release, Barrell blended bourbons aged 12 to 17 years from Kentucky, Indiana, Tennessee, and Wyoming. Barrell finished the blend in French oak casks with varying toast levels, primarily using a technique called Grand Chauffe.
Rather than applying intense heat for a short period, Grand Chauffe uses lower heat over a longer time. The idea is to develop deeper flavors while preserving the bourbon's character underneath.
Barrell describes a profile of toasted brioche, vanilla custard, roasted nuts, cinnamon, clove, and crème brûlée. It's an ambitious flavor target, but one that makes sense given the finishing process.
Tasting Notes
Aroma
The nose leans heavily into toasted nuts, vanilla, caramel, and oak. It's warm and inviting, with very little fruit to speak of. There's a nice richness here, but it's the toasted character that stands out. You can tell the oak is going to play a major role in this whiskey.
Taste
The palate is where the name starts making sense. Creamy vanilla and cinnamon lead the way, followed by clove, earthy notes, and just a hint of mint. There's a pleasant sweetness and a decent mouthfeel that helps bring everything together.
And yes, it really does remind us of French toast. Maybe even more like a warm bread pudding. It's an interesting profile, and one we enjoyed more than we expected from a whiskey built around such a specific flavor concept.
Finish
This is where things change. As the sweeter flavors fade, the oak becomes more dominant. The finish turns dry and tannic, leaving behind a woody character that doesn't quite fit with the richness of the palate.
We don't mind oak. Especially in older bourbon. But here, the French oak feels a little too aggressive, and the finish ends up being our least favorite part of the experience.
Artfully Bourbon Rating
7 / 10 - Good
Barrell French Toast(ed) is a good whiskey with a genuinely interesting flavor profile. The combination of mature bourbon and toasted French oak delivers something distinctive, and the dessert inspiration isn't just clever marketing. But we couldn't quite get past the finish. What makes this bottle interesting is also what holds it back. The French oak adds character, but it ultimately becomes more noticeable than we'd like.
We both preferred Barrell's Toasted American Oak release. That whiskey struck a better balance for our tastes, allowing the bourbon and the finishing process to complement each other rather than compete.
French Toast(ed) still earns a respectable 7 out of 10. We enjoyed drinking it. We just weren't completely sold on the overall experience.
Buy or Skip:
Pass
There's a difference between appreciating what went into a whiskey and wanting to spend your own money on another bottle.
We appreciate the blending, the age, and the experimentation behind French Toast(ed). And for someone who loves heavily toasted French oak, this might be exactly what they're looking for.
But at $160, we'd rather put our money toward the American Oak release or another bottle that delivers a more balanced experience. French Toast(ed) gets surprisingly close to the dessert that inspired it. We just wish the oak knew when to stop.
Where Does It Rank?
Every whiskey we review is scored using the same 10-point scale, making it easy to compare bottles across styles, distilleries, and price points. Explore our complete whiskey rankings to see how every bottle stacks up.
Related Reviews We Think You’ll Enjoy
Shop the Artfully Bourbon Mercantile
An everyday tee with a little more character.
The AB Field Supply Tee is lightweight, soft, and easy to wear on its own or under a jacket. A clean front graphic and subtle sleeve detail give it just enough personality without overworking it.
Built for bottle runs, backyard hangs, and wherever the day goes.
Details
- Lightweight 4.3 oz. cotton
- Classic crew neckline
- Regular fit
- Side-seamed construction
- Shoulder taping for durability
Care
Machine wash cold. Tumble dry low. Iron on low. Do not bleach or dry clean.
GEAR GUIDE
Looking for the glasses, tools, books, studio gear, and other things we use? We’ve collected our favorites in one place.
As an Amazon Associate, Artfully Bourbon earns from qualifying purchases.