We’re back with another round of rye whiskey, ranking every bottle from S Tier all the way down. This time, the competition gets even tougher, with more bottles fighting for the top spots and a few that surprised us.

We’re ranking 10 rye whiskeys from top to bottom in our Ultimate Rye Whiskey Tier List. From easy drinkers to bold, high-proof bottles, we’re putting them head-to-head and deciding which ryes belong in S Tier and which ones don’t make the cut.